Hat-Tricks for Stoke

Some rare downtime and we came across an article on CricInfo relating to hat-tricks and their importance & ranking. With thanks to Anantha at CricInfo for devising a methodology, and Gus Atkinson doing his thing in New Zealand recently let’s take a look at ours.

We have a much smaller sample of hat-tricks with accurate records only kept since 1990, so apologies to some of the Stoke greats who may have managed one before then. There have only been fifteen, taken by thirteen different bowlers since then:

Mike Cooper v Southbank in 1999
Ian Grant v Southern Railway in 1999 – on debut
Gary Harkett v President’s XI in 2001
Adrian Mills v Ottershaw in 2003
Andy Lee v Ottershaw in 2004 – four wickets in four balls
Dave Edwards (NZ) v Merstham in 2005
Siddhartha Lahiri v Woodmansterne in 2006
Ralph Coleman v Warlingham in 2013
Harry Ross v Caterham in 2013
Nico Spreeth v Alleyn in 2015
Toby Tarrant v Old Emanuel in 2016
Ralph Coleman v Kingstonian in 2019
Justin Jones v Leatherhead in 2020
Ben Page v Usk in 2024
Ben Page v Hampton Hill 2024

More detail here: Hat-Tricks

Let’s look at Anantha’s methodology:

Quality of batters dismissed
The quality of the batters dismissed is determined by the career batting averages of those dismissed. We look at the career figures rather than the career-to-date figures so that there is a degree of constancy to the analysis, in that the value for a batter will remain the same whenever he was dismissed. Also, it does not really matter what we use. Career batting averages make for easier evaluation.

Aided by dismissing a batter with a career average of 54.24, Nico Spreeth’s 1st XI hat-trick against Alleyn in 2015 scored highest, (aggregate batting averages of 82.98); although honourable mentions to Sid Lahiri, (aggregate 76.32), and Ben Page whose two hat-tricks accounted for batters with aggregate career averages over 70.00. At the other end of the scale Andy Lee dismissed three batters for a duck, and their combined career averages were just 15.69.

Top-order index of batters dismissed
This index is to recognise and reward the importance of dismissing top-order batters. Anantha has given both openers the index value of 1. The batters from No.3 onwards are assigned index values of 2 to 10. This is to ensure that the sum of the batting position is a meaningful one. The lowest value for the batting position index is four – the two opening batters and the No.3. Until the recent rule change, this was more likely with the batters being allowed to cross over when a batter was caught.

Here we have a clear winner. Toby Tarrant’s three in three against Old Emanuel in 2016, (a match we went on to lose), scored an index of 6; batters 3 and 4 followed by an opener at the beginning of the next over. Only three Test hat-tricks, (taken by Wasim Akram, Nuwan Zoysa and Irfan Pathan), can match this. We could also make a case for this being a better hat-trick than his Zero Ducks Given co-host Steven Finn whose World Cup hat-trick at the MCG in 2015 took out batters 7, 9 and 10…OK they were Brad Haddin, Glenn Maxwell and Mitchell Johnson but we are confident Toby would have seen those off as well if given the chance. A tale of the tape is on the extra tab. At the other end of the scale Gary Harkett and Ben Page dismissed batters 9/10/11 although the latter’s may have picked up better batters in a reversed batting order. An argument here is that 3/4/5 could arguably be of equal or better standard than an opener but no other Stoke hat-tricks were made up of three top five batters in the order.

Aggregate runs of batters dismissed
This index allows us to identify the bowlers who achieved something special – dismissing all the hat-trick victims for 0. A high value of the index indicates that the hat-trick was launched by dismissing a set batter at a relatively high score.

Again, one of our hat-tricks matches this. Andy Lee took out batters 6, 7 and 8 all for ducks…and didn’t stop there as he proceeded to take four wickets in four balls, number 9 for a duck…and later No.10 was removed for a quacker as well. This was part of astonishing figures of 7.5-5-12-8, a record for us in 2nd XI League cricket, and the second best analysis in a 2nd XI match ever. We are grateful to Adrian Mills for some more anecdotal evidence on this match:

“The hat-trick ball was caught by Keith Watson diving in front of first slip…he had new keeping gear that day and it stuck in the webbing between thumb and index finger. That would make numbers 6,7,8 with 9 becoming the 4 in 4. They were 17 for 9 at one point as we knew what the league lowest score was at the time. We would have beaten it too but there was a dropped catch that would have finished the game. In the next over the old guy batting at 11 whacked two fours before missing a straight one.”

Seven Test hat-tricks have achieved the feat of dismissing all batters for ducks.

Team summary
Anantha’s summary was by Test playing nations. Obviously we have no comparison but interestingly six of our hat-tricks were in 1st XI League games, and you could argue that Ben Page’s T20 hat-trick this year was of the same quality of fixture, (1st XI not Test that is); so could we conclude that the bowling needs to be accurate and better than the batting for a hat-trick rather than a bowler running into two or three batters with lesser competence?

OTHER ANALYTICAL SNIPPETS

Innings splits
The first classification is to group the hat-tricks in the innings they were taken.

Innings 1: 8
Innings 2: 7

Results summary
Onwards to the classification-based on results. No surprises here. When a hat-trick occurs, it increases the probability of a result, although four people have been unlucky to take a hat-trick and end up on the losing side.

Won: 11
Lost: 4

Location summary
Unlike the list of Test hat-tricks, more Stoke hat-tricks have been taken at home than away.

Home: 9
Away: 6

Year summary
The year 1999 saw four Test hat-tricks. We had two of our own that year, and another two in 2013 and 2024, both this year taken by Ben Page.

Decade summary
The 2000s and 2010s both had five hat-tricks. Half way through the current decade and we have three already so are we on course for a record?

1990s: 2
2000s: 5
2010s: 5
2020s: 3 so far

Bowler type summary
There was a 29:17 split between seam:spin when looking at the Test hat-tricks. Our breakdown is heavily weighted towards seam bowlers.

Right-arm fast/medium: 13
Left-arm spin: 1
Off spin: 1

Six test hat-tricks were taken by left-arm seamers. Zero for us; maybe something for Dan Risk, Andy Butler and Mark Duncan to aspire to add to their CVs!

Country summary
Obviously not much we can analyse here, but Ben Page can lay claim to having taken one in Wales.

NUGGETS

Two hat-tricks in career
Ralphie joins Ben Page on the list, although his were taken against far inferior opposition.

Unaided hat-tricks
Sid Lahiri and Ben Page, (second hat-trick), were all their own work if you exclude umpires. The third was very much one-man’s work. The first two wickets in Harry Ross’ hat-trick were return catches and then the third was bowled. Note that like Toby Tarrant’s, the hat-trick spanned two overs. We checked this with Harry who is still in touch with the Club despite currently building a career as an opera singer in Dusseldorf!

Identical dismissal hat-tricks
Three of our hat-tricks were made up of a catch and two bowleds. Only Toby Tarrant needed assists from fielders and keepers; although Ian Grant and Justin Jones both needed stumpings courtesy of James Haddow and Andy Berry respectively.

Special hat-tricks
Harry Ross and Toby Tarrant are the two to take hat-tricks over two overs.

Debut hat-tricks
Ian Grant holds the distinction of taking a hat-trick on debut. A very late call up in the 1999 season where it was a constant struggle to raise a 1st XI, let alone the three Saturday XIs we run today, he was brought on very late in a fielding effort at Southern Railway and collected two ‘in’ batters, both with career averages of 30.00 as part of his three-in-three. Despite this, Ian’s Stoke career lasted just six matches and 25 overs including the 2-0-8-3 he returned on his big day.

Highest score at fall of the first wicket
As mentioned above Ian was brought on very late, taking his hat-trick with the total on 187; but there have been higher totals at the start of the chaos; Adrian Mills taking his three with the Ottershaw total on 217 and Sid Lahiri 198 versus Woodmansterne.

Anantha suggests that arguably these are the least useful of hat-tricks; although Sid’s did result in a win where we chased down a big score.

Lowest number of career wickets with a hat-trick
Ian Grant’s wickets were three of just six wickets he would take for the Club. Harry Ross only took 31, and they are split by Justin Jones whose Over 40s hat-trick off the last three balls of an innings account for a quarter of his current Stoke tally.

The others have all had to put in a big shift before their time to shine came along.

Player involvement
From above the breakdown of dismissals within the 45 wickets are:

Caught: 20 (including three caught & bowled)
Bowled : 18
LBW: 5
Stumped: 2

Close matches
The closest game involving a hat-trick was in 2005 when the New Zealand Dave Edwards, (not the 10273 run/1287 wicket Stoke legend with the same name), helped Stoke defend 130. Merstham could only make 121 for 9 in reply; a crazy scorecard where the opposing opening bat made an unbeaten 86, and the last wicket added an unbeaten 34 to test nerves. Andy Lee’s demolition of Ottershaw oversaw a win by 172 runs, (a match in which Alistair McMillan made a century); and Ralphie’s first hat-trick against Warlingham led to a 10 wicket win, although the heavens opened soon after.

Innings wickets captured
Six of the hat-tricks were the bowlers’ only wickets in the innings.

Hat-tricks off the first and last balls of match
No-one has started a match with such devastation. Only Ben Page’s tour hat-trick finished a match. Justin Jones’ effort was off the last three balls of the first innings but the opposition were not bowled out.

Month of occurrence
More fixtures being played in May, June and July would be a probable reason for this breakdown…

April: 1
May: 5
June: 4
July: 3
August: 1
September: 1

…although only one August hat-trick; maybe harder for the bowlers as pitches are at their best?

Conclusions?
So given this list – Hat-Tricks – how would you rank these? Game-changing? All wickets unaided? Contributing to a close win? Taking out higher quality batters with good career averages or ‘in’ batters at the time?

E-mail stokecc@hotmail.com with your views and we’ll publish them here.

Original source article: https://www.espncricinfo.com/story/where-does-irfan-pathan-s-karachi-triple-strike-rank-on-the-list-of-the-greatest-hat-tricks-anantha-narayanan-1458522