Saturday’s 2nd XI win at Woking & Horsell was one for the ages; Kane Fullalove’s match double of 50+ runs/5+ wickets being just the third instance in the Surrey Championship era by a Stoke player; the others being:
Johnny Lawes, (Surrey’s Tom’s dad for those who don’t know), sending down 13-2-54-5 then hitting 105 not out to win a game at Sinjungrammarians in June 2011 (Match 1 in the index at the foot of this article)
and
Keith Medlycott returning figures of 22-1-81-5 then hitting 54 at Oxted & Limpsfield in August 2014 (2) on Will Gudgeon’s wedding day.
There were no instances in the Fuller’s League, the nearest being Alistair McMillan’s 49 followed up by 5-54 against Merrow in 2006 (3); nor in the old South West London League that we played one season in in 1972.
There were two match doubles in the Wey Valley League era, (1973 to 1993), one in our last appearance in that competition:
Roy Johns 5-29 & 56 v Thames Ditton Wanderers in June 1991 (4)
Gary Harkett 53 & 6-24 v Milford in August 1993 (5)
However the most remarkable thing about Saturday’s result was victory from a such a precarious position with the bat. 0-2 after five balls then 3-3 after 5.3 overs, yet ending on 248 for 9 declared.
The worst start, yet ending up victorious, was Logie Logendran’s promotion winning 2nd XI in 1996. Against Old Wimbledonians (6) they were 0-3 and 22 for 5 before scrambling up to 143 all out courtesy of double-digit contributions by Chris Finch, James Haddow, Rick Mustill, Gary Harkett, Tony Trotman and Neil Brooker, (some legends knowing what to do there!), before unleashing Trotman, (4-36), Harkett, (3-12), and others to secure an 81 run win.
Following this article, (https://www.espncricinfo.com/story/which-teams-recovered-from-24-for-6-and-26-for-6-to-win-tests-anantha-narayanan-1428511), we had been looking at great comebacks from 5-down, 6-down, 7-down, 8-down and even 9-down. For those not so keen to read that article in full, basically it looked at:
• Most runs scored since the fall of the 5th, 6th, 7th, 8th and 9th wickets
• More than 100 runs scored by the team after the fall of that wicket
• The Final Score/Runs Scored at Fall ratio (FS/RW)
Take Saturday’s game (7)…
From 103 for 5 Stoke made it up to 248, an increase to the total of 145, and an FS/RW ratio of 2.41 (248/103); and there have been only five instances of a Stoke 2nd XI scoring more than 145 runs after the fall of the fifth wicket:
176 68-5 to 244ao v Chertsey in 2013 (8)
171 127-5 to 298-7 v Sinjungrammarians in 2016 (9)
166 66-5 to 232ao v Chipstead (Away) in 2013 (10)
162 66-5 to 228ao v Chipstead (Home) in 2013 (11)
151 60-5 to 211ao v Ripley in 2016 (12)
145 Saturday (7)
The home matches against Chipstead and Ripley were drawn, the others all resulted in wins.
Yesterday’s FS/RW ratio is quite low down on the list however as the fifth wicket fell on 103; the best – for the 2s – being the aforementioned game against the OWs in 1996 (6) where 22-5 to 143ao had a ratio of 6.50.
In terms of high ratios resulting in wins; the Chertsey and Chipstead (Away) matches from 2013 beat yesterday, as does the one instance where we have a League last wicket stand of 100+ – step forward Alex Shipp & Tristan Caviet who took Stoke from 97-9 to 215ao against Blackheath in 1998 (13), (we were 74-5 in that one); and other Fuller’s games against Alleyn Old Boys in July 1998 (14), (73-5 to 196ao), and Puttenham in 1996 (15), (Logie’s team – again! – was 68-5 before getting up to 180-9.) The only other to beat yesterday was a recent home game against Hampton Hill in 2021 (16) where Jack Raimondo and Jase Earl built a recovery from 88-5 to set up a winning total of 222-9.
At 1st XI level there is one game where the FS/RW ratio smashes all others. Against Beddington in the last game of 2021 (17) Stoke were 9-5 but Ian Hopton, (69), and Ben Townsend, (44), helped get us up to 140 all out; although that game was lost relatively comfortably. A whopping FS/RW ratio of 15.56 there, next highest was the 1996 Old Wimbledonians match (6) already discussed.
The best FS/RW ratio in a winning cause for the 1st XI in the Surrey Championship era was in June 2017 when Stoke were 73-5 against Weybridge Vandals (18) but Will Gudgeon went berserk, hit 114 and Stoke ended on 274ao. (FS/RW 3.75) Dan Gluckman, Kane, (did he play the way he did yesterday with that game in mind?), and Toby Tarrant providing double-digit assists with the bat.
The only 1st XI game to beat that ratio in any League era was our first ever win in the Fuller’s League at Ewhurst in 1994 (19), (46-5 to 232-8 declared – FS/RW 5.04), and third on that list was the other game played on Will Gudgeon’s wedding day when Stoke were 51-5 chasing 177 against Godalming (20); but Matt Gottschalk with 50 not out and James Corbishley making an unbeaten 38 had everyone singing the Stoke victory song on the dancefloor in Coventry. Was that really ten years ago this week?!?!
The 3rd XI had a mad game against Chessington (21) last season; 36-5, 36-6 and 65-7 but still managed to reach 158 for 9 batting second to win. Carel Ferreira, (63 not out), and Alex Bond, (40) turning that match. The other FS/RW ratio over 5.00 in a winning cause came in a Trust League game against Malden Wanderers in 2012 (22) where Will Gudgeon, (73), and Matt Gottschalk, (38), rescued Stoke from 34-5 to get us up to 171 all out and set up a 77 run win.
To compete things, the most runs scored after the fall of the 5th wicket in any match was 206 against Churt in 2015 (23). Stoke went from 99-5 – and 99-6 – to 305-9. That man Gudgeon again weighed in with 154, Giacomo Gray 37 and James Whitmarsh 30 providing major assists. The only other 200+ increment to a score after being five wickets down was the Weybridge Vandals game (18) mentioned earlier.
A recent biggie in world cricket was the Glenn Maxwell match against Afghanistan. Australia went from 69-5 to 293-7; an FS/RW ratio of 4.24 and 224 runs scored after the fifth wicket, 206 after the 6th and 202 after the 7th! We have never scored more runs after the 5th/6th/7th wickets that that – although the 2015 game against Churt (23) equals runs after 6th! – but we do have nine instances of a higher FS/RW ratios from five wickets down.
So before fearing the worst at not many runs for 3 or 5 – or even more wickets down – take inspiration from Saturday and the other games mentioned here that have been won from seemingly precarious or perceived impossible positions!
MATCH INDEX
(1) Sinjungrammarians 2011 – https://sdacc.play-cricket.com/website/results/1608657
(2) Oxted 2014 – https://sdacc.play-cricket.com/website/results/2179213
(3) Merrow 2006 – https://sdacc.play-cricket.com/website/results/791556
(4) Thames Ditton Wanderers 1991 – https://sdacc.play-cricket.com/website/results/1289271
(5) Milford 1993 – https://sdacc.play-cricket.com/website/results/1609447
(6) Old Wimbledonians 1996 – https://sdacc.play-cricket.com/website/results/2314199
(7) Woking & Horsell 2024 – https://sdacc.play-cricket.com/website/results/6179184
(8) Chertsey 2013 – https://sdacc.play-cricket.com/website/results/1944073
(9) Sinjungrammarians 2016 – https://sdacc.play-cricket.com/website/results/2804164
(10) Chipstead (Away) 2013 – https://sdacc.play-cricket.com/website/results/1944091
(11) Chipstead (Home) 2013 – https://sdacc.play-cricket.com/website/results/1944132
(12) Ripley 2016 – https://sdacc.play-cricket.com/website/results/2804162
(13) Blackheath 1998 – https://sdacc.play-cricket.com/website/results/2308561
(14) Alleyn Old Boys 1998 – https://sdacc.play-cricket.com/website/results/2308556
(15) Puttenham & Wanborough 1996 – https://sdacc.play-cricket.com/website/results/2314200
(16) Hampton Hill 2021 – https://sdacc.play-cricket.com/website/results/4580679
(17) Beddington 2021 – https://sdacc.play-cricket.com/website/results/4581885
(18) Weybridge Vandals 2017 – https://sdacc.play-cricket.com/website/results/2897028
(19) Ewhurst 1994 – https://sdacc.play-cricket.com/website/results/2317688
(20) Godalming 2015 – https://sdacc.play-cricket.com/website/results/2179600
(21) Chessington 2023 – https://sdacc.play-cricket.com/website/results/5540792
(22) Malden Wanderers 2012 – https://sdacc.play-cricket.com/website/results/1793280
(23) Churt 2015 – https://sdacc.play-cricket.com/website/results/2470268