“I get out caught a lot”

Followers of our Twitter page would have seen us recently capture details of our active players with the most number of innings having never been dismissed leg before. (For those who hadn’t seen it Geoff Vinall tops that list with a current run of 51 innings from debut and never been lbw.)

However in the comments under that tweet, another player on that list, Fraser Slater, (who has not been out lbw in any of his 20 career innings for the Club so far), was quick to mention that whilst he has never been out leg before “…I do get out caught a lot!”

That got us thinking and we took a look at people who have been dismissed caught to see if the above comment was just perception or whether there were any facts behind it.

Using the same minimum 20 innings as for the lbw analysis, Fraser appears to be very observant!

Let’s look at things in two ways:
(1) Out caught as a percentage of the number of times out
(2) Out caught as a percentage of the number of all innings, (including not outs)

(1) Whenever you’re out you’re out caught!

Fraser has been not out 5 times in his 20 innings for the Club, and has been out caught 10 times from his 15 dismissals, 66.67%.

On the list of active players Fraser is joint second with Billy Zander, the pair behind only Luke Patterson on the below image.

This first list looks at the highest 40 percentages for active players. The overall percentage of “when you’re out you’re out caught” for the all-time list of all players is 45.39% and all bar two of these active players have been out caught more often. Beneath the overall Club percentage we add Ben Townsend, (first guy on the list under 45.39%), to demonstrate that further down the percentages drop as we start to come across more people who reputedly class bowling as their stronger suit. Arman Zaheen sneaks in with his percentage reduced courtesy of his obstructing the field dismissal in August.


You may need to click on the image to enlarge it depending on which device you are reading this on

When introducing former and inactive players to this list Luke is still 5th all-time; only Shawn Dyson, (74.36%), Nic Carlino, (73.91%), Johnny Lawes, (73.44%), and James O’Gorman, (71.43%), are above him.

Whilst this article only looks at senior matches, when filtering on age group cricket Luke’s younger brother Mark has been out 20 times in those matches, and been out caught 14 times, (70%) – something for the family’s coach to work on there, perhaps?!?

(2) Whenever you bat you’re out caught!

So how does the table vary when considering all innings? If you include all not outs, the all-time percentage of dismissals caught for the Club drops to 37.77%.

Here is how the list changes; Stephen Finch and Peter Phipps are immediately either side of that overall percentage, Phippsy not making it on the first list having only been out caught 42.07% of the time…when out:


You may need to click on the image to enlarge it depending on which device you are reading this on

Here you see more opening batters jump towards the top of the list; as they’re seldom not out and their percentages of innings played and out caught do change that much. Middle and lower order players have more chance to be not out so their percentages naturally drop. Are those nearer the bottom of this list less protective of their stumps or do they just hit the ball in the air less? You be the judge!

Fraser drops from joint 2nd to 13th between the two lists – Max Subba Row and Malcolm Dickson jump higher from the first list to the second which could support the comments in the previous paragraph about opening batters.

To complete the analysis the all-time list shows little change at the top. With Shawn having a few not outs to reduce his percentage to 58.00%, Nic Carlino assumes top spot with 68.00%, followed by Johnny Lawes, (66.20%) Rupert Style, an opening bat by trade, jumps to third on the list; he walked off the playing area out caught 65.22% of the time – as opposed to 68.18% when looking at just his dismissals and excluding his solitary not out; then Luke Patterson is next, continuing to fly the flag for the active players.

Any thoughts? We’d love to hear from you…

A final note, unconnected to the above, is that not only is Fraser a great bloke, statistically he’s a guy you want on your team. In his 20 appearances for the Club so far he has been on the winning side 14 times. No player with a minimum of 20 appearances for the Club can beat his 70% win rate…maybe a “Most Winningest Team” for some or all of our XIs is the next thing to look at! Watch this space…